Group Micro-Teaching

 Our group members: Medha, Malik, Francisco, Mahnaz


Lesson Plan: Trigonometric Identities in Pre-Calculus 12

Here is the lesson plan in detail:

Lesson Plan: The Trigonometric Identities
Course: Pre-Calculus 12 | Time: 15 minutes | Co-Teachers: Medha, Malik, Francisco, Mahnaz

Learning Objectives:
By the end of the lesson, students will be able to:
1. Identify Illegal moves in algebraic proofs (like cross-multiplying, possible zeroes.

2. Use algebraic strategies (like common denominators, conjugates) to prove an identity.

3. Construct a proof.

Space and Material:
Space: classroom, group seating

Material: Handouts, Mini whiteboards, Whiteboard Markers. 


Lesson Flow

Time

Teacher in lead

Teacher Instructions

Student Action

4 mins

Francisco

The hook: The Flawed Proof: On the board
Prove that 1 = -2.
Let x = π, then
sin(x) = 0 and cos(x) = -1
sin(x) = sin(2x)  (because sinπ = 0 and sin(2π) = 0)

{"id":"2","backgroundColor":"#ffffff","type":"$$","font":{"family":"Arial","size":12,"color":"#0f1115"},"code":"$$\\frac{\\sin x}{\\sin x}=\\frac{\\sin2x}{\\sin x}$$","fontColorModified":false,"aid":null,"backgroundColorModified":false,"ts":1792533489347,"cs":"EZZRC3OynvNHNnLdquj9+Q==","size":{"width":120,"height":37,"verticalAlign":-13.09}}
{"font":{"size":11,"color":"#000000","family":"Arial"},"type":"$$","aid":null,"fontColorModified":false,"id":"3","code":"$$1=\\frac{2\\,\\sin x.\\,\\cos x}{\\sin x}$$","backgroundColorModified":false,"backgroundColor":"#ffffff","ts":1792533536392,"cs":"yKvdnMADTqBCUo42UEGv9A==","size":{"width":129,"height":34,"verticalAlign":-12.03}}
1 = 2cos(x)
1 = 2(-1)
1 = -2

Provocative Question: Where is the lie? Who can catch the error?

Students share possible reasons why that might have happened. Where might the error be?


Medha

Gather the ideas and direct them towards the division step.
Guiding Question: What are we dividing by? Is it allowed to be zero at any given x value?


Important Idea to be careful about:
When proving identities, you cannot cross-multiply, and you can not divide by zero. You must work down one side.

Do you know why?

Students will share their POVs on where the sine value will be zero and how we can avoid dividing by zero



5
mins

Malik

Explains the process of avoiding division by zero: on the board:

Prove: {"id":"4","font":{"family":"Arial","color":"#000000","size":11},"fontColorModified":false,"aid":null,"type":"$$","code":"$$\\frac{1-\\cos x}{\\sin x}=\\frac{\\sin x}{1+\\cos x}$$","backgroundColor":"#ffffff","backgroundColorModified":false,"ts":1792533690788,"cs":"3TO3iuO/df6WjDD9lhqxSA==","size":{"width":164,"height":36,"verticalAlign":-13.36}}

Question: If we can’t cross-multiply, where do we start?
Strategy:
We want the denominator on the left-hand side to look like the denominator on the right-hand side, using the conjugate.

Students Think-Pair- Share for 1.5 minutes


Mahnaz +

Medha (To point towards the identity we use) 

Strategy cont.:

Step 1: Multiply top and bottom by (1 + cos x).

Step 2: Numerator becomes  {"backgroundColor":"#ffffff","type":"$$","font":{"color":"#0f1115","family":"Arial","size":12},"backgroundColorModified":false,"fontColorModified":false,"aid":null,"id":"5","code":"$$1 - cos^{2}(x)$$","ts":1792534505470,"cs":"MZ/wBDlQ+fevAmaqCQtAkg==","size":{"width":88,"height":20,"verticalAlign":-4.74}}. Denominator becomes (sin x)(1 + cos x).

Step 3: Medha jumps in and asks the class: "What identity turns {"backgroundColor":"#ffffff","type":"$$","font":{"color":"#0f1115","family":"Arial","size":12},"backgroundColorModified":false,"fontColorModified":false,"aid":null,"id":"5","code":"$$1 - cos^{2}(x)$$","ts":1792534505470,"cs":"MZ/wBDlQ+fevAmaqCQtAkg==","size":{"width":88,"height":20,"verticalAlign":-4.74}} into something with sine?"

Step 4: Mahnaz cancels the sin x:
{"fontColorModified":false,"code":"$$\\frac{\\sin x}{1+\\cos x}$$","id":"7","type":"$$","aid":null,"backgroundColor":"#ffffff","font":{"color":"#000000","family":"Arial","size":12},"backgroundColorModified":false,"ts":1792534690985,"cs":"XEhRpdVa9Rb73rGRLzrXoA==","size":{"width":74,"height":40,"verticalAlign":-14.42}}

The class answers:{"fontColorModified":false,"font":{"color":"#0f1115","family":"Arial","size":12},"id":"6","aid":null,"type":"$$","backgroundColor":"#ffffff","backgroundColorModified":false,"code":"$$sin^{2}(x)$$","ts":1792534590497,"cs":"//7K17s0RRoEOCDSn/YR0A==","size":{"width":56,"height":20,"verticalAlign":-4.74}}. 


Francisco

Notice we never cross-multiplied. We just transformed the left side until it matches the right side.


3
mins

ALL

  1. All 4 teachers divide the room into 4 groups and assign them sections of the whiteboard

  2. The groups must prove
    {"backgroundColorModified":false,"aid":null,"backgroundColor":"#ffffff","code":"$$\\sec x\\,-\\,\\cos x\\,=\\,\\tan x\\,.\\,\\sin x\\,$$","font":{"color":"#000000","family":"Arial","size":11},"type":"$$","fontColorModified":false,"id":"8","ts":1792534895554,"cs":"D96SKYVGcQgGphrUpF7N5w==","size":{"width":209,"height":12,"verticalAlign":-0.21}}

  3. Challenge for High performers:

Students get divided into groups of 4 and start working on the problem on the board. 

3 mins

Medha
+
Mahnaz

Starts the timer and asks one group to share their ideas, and Mahnaz can follow the student steps to write the final proof given by the students

Students share their ideas and reasoning for their steps. 

1 min

Malik
+
Francisco

Wrap up and Formative assessment:
Malik asks the class to do a quick fist-to-five hold-up of fingers:
0-1=completely lost, 2-3 trying to make connections, 4-5 feeling confident
Francisco asks a final check-for-understanding.
What is the golden nugget you learnt in this lesson?
Malik: Next lesson we will use these same strategies to solve equations.

Expected answer from the students:
Work down one side; do not cross-multiply any function with a possible zero value


Teacher's Note

Flawed Proof:

Prove that 1 = -2.
Let x = π, then
sin(x) = 0 and cos(x) = -1
sin(x) = sin(2x) 
{"id":"2","backgroundColor":"#ffffff","type":"$$","font":{"family":"Arial","size":12,"color":"#0f1115"},"code":"$$\\frac{\\sin x}{\\sin x}=\\frac{\\sin2x}{\\sin x}$$","fontColorModified":false,"aid":null,"backgroundColorModified":false,"ts":1792533489347,"cs":"EZZRC3OynvNHNnLdquj9+Q==","size":{"width":120,"height":37,"verticalAlign":-13.09}}
{"font":{"size":11,"color":"#000000","family":"Arial"},"type":"$$","aid":null,"fontColorModified":false,"id":"3","code":"$$1=\\frac{2\\,\\sin x.\\,\\cos x}{\\sin x}$$","backgroundColorModified":false,"backgroundColor":"#ffffff","ts":1792533536392,"cs":"yKvdnMADTqBCUo42UEGv9A==","size":{"width":129,"height":34,"verticalAlign":-12.03}}
1 = 2cos(x)
1 = 2(-1)
1 = -2

Model Proof:
Prove: {"id":"4","font":{"family":"Arial","color":"#000000","size":11},"fontColorModified":false,"aid":null,"type":"$$","code":"$$\\frac{1-\\cos x}{\\sin x}=\\frac{\\sin x}{1+\\cos x}$$","backgroundColor":"#ffffff","backgroundColorModified":false,"ts":1792533690788,"cs":"3TO3iuO/df6WjDD9lhqxSA==","size":{"width":164,"height":36,"verticalAlign":-13.36}}
L.S. =

= {"code":"$$\\frac{\\left(1-\\cos x\\right)\\left(1+\\cos x\\right)}{\\sin x\\left(1+\\cos x\\right)}$$","backgroundColorModified":false,"backgroundColor":"#ffffff","type":"$$","fontColorModified":false,"font":{"family":"Arial","size":12,"color":"#0f1115"},"aid":null,"id":"9","ts":1792537638214,"cs":"qiqNXa9qJbN3HNtVwBD19w==","size":{"width":178,"height":45,"verticalAlign":-18.1}}
= {"font":{"color":"#0f1115","size":12,"family":"Arial"},"type":"$$","id":"10","backgroundColor":"#ffffff","code":"$$\\frac{1 - cos^{2} x}{\\sin x\\left(1+\\cos x\\right)}$$","aid":null,"fontColorModified":false,"backgroundColorModified":false,"ts":1792537681333,"cs":"oRe6Rdye7PD8xwbJy+OQaQ==","size":{"width":129,"height":46,"verticalAlign":-18.16}}
={"backgroundColor":"#ffffff","code":"$$\\frac{sin^{2} x}{\\sin x\\left(1+\\cos x\\right)}$$","id":"11","font":{"size":12,"family":"Arial","color":"#0f1115"},"aid":null,"backgroundColorModified":false,"fontColorModified":false,"type":"$$","ts":1792537736235,"cs":"QbrT0uE9tspwb57IY8vD/w==","size":{"width":129,"height":46,"verticalAlign":-18.16}}

={"backgroundColor":"#ffffff","font":{"color":"#000000","size":11,"family":"Arial"},"fontColorModified":false,"aid":null,"backgroundColorModified":false,"id":"12","type":"$$","code":"$$\\frac{\\sin x}{1+\\cos x}$$","ts":1792537758928,"cs":"MXBMtnTVgo+n1q0dtPW/mg==","size":{"width":68,"height":36,"verticalAlign":-13.36}}
= R.S.

Group Activity Proof:
Prove: {"backgroundColorModified":false,"aid":null,"backgroundColor":"#ffffff","code":"$$\\sec x\\,-\\,\\cos x\\,=\\,\\tan x\\,.\\,\\sin x\\,$$","font":{"color":"#000000","family":"Arial","size":11},"type":"$$","fontColorModified":false,"id":"8","ts":1792534895554,"cs":"D96SKYVGcQgGphrUpF7N5w==","size":{"width":209,"height":12,"verticalAlign":-0.21}}
L.S. {"fontColorModified":false,"code":"$$=\\sec x-\\cos x$$","backgroundColor":"#ffffff","backgroundColorModified":false,"font":{"size":11,"color":"#000000","family":"Arial"},"type":"$$","id":"13","aid":null,"ts":1792537847469,"cs":"S+T17svGcoSx8Vs1SlDjxA==","size":{"width":108,"height":8,"verticalAlign":-0.21}}
=    {"type":"$$","backgroundColorModified":false,"id":"14","font":{"family":"Arial","size":11,"color":"#000000"},"code":"$$\\frac{1}{\\cos x}-\\cos x$$","backgroundColor":"#ffffff","fontColorModified":false,"aid":null,"ts":1792537882669,"cs":"7jaUTVrBNeW47ry4D613Lw==","size":{"width":96,"height":34,"verticalAlign":-12.08}}
{"aid":null,"fontColorModified":false,"type":"$$","backgroundColor":"#ffffff","code":"$$=\\frac{1-\\cos^{2}x}{\\cos x}$$","id":"15","backgroundColorModified":false,"font":{"family":"Arial","size":12,"color":"#0f1115"},"ts":1792537951598,"cs":"n+a8S6OGVdnnQ4eYnBfo1g==","size":{"width":104,"height":41,"verticalAlign":-13.16}}
{"code":"$$=sin^{2} x / cos x$$","id":"16","font":{"family":"Arial","color":"#0f1115","size":12},"backgroundColorModified":false,"backgroundColor":"#ffffff","fontColorModified":false,"aid":null,"type":"$$","ts":1792537982985,"cs":"aSQSVjSsAuzxZZMCCVtAFQ==","size":{"width":109,"height":20,"verticalAlign":-4.74}}
{"type":"$$","backgroundColorModified":false,"code":"$$=\\frac{\\sin x}{\\cos x}\\sin x$$","aid":null,"font":{"size":12,"family":"Arial","color":"#0f1115"},"id":"17","backgroundColor":"#ffffff","fontColorModified":false,"ts":1792538034634,"cs":"0r3HVzEA2jOc1fig1Mvh4g==","size":{"width":101,"height":37,"verticalAlign":-13.09}}

{"aid":null,"backgroundColor":"#ffffff","backgroundColorModified":false,"fontColorModified":false,"type":"$$","id":"19","code":"$$=\\,\\tan x.\\,\\sin x$$","font":{"size":11,"family":"Arial","color":"#000000"},"ts":1792538085081,"cs":"mSJeYhEWJQOjpZyP/aInfw==","size":{"width":100,"height":12,"verticalAlign":-0.21}}
= R.S.


Comments

  1. Hi Francisco, Mahnaz, Malik and Medha! A very cool and exciting lesson with lots of interesting explorations. However -- I am quite worried about the timing! Your listed timings already add up to 16 minutes, rather than 15, and you will only get 15 minutes. I think you may have underestimated the time it could take to teach each part of this as well. Please check your lesson plan carefully and figure out where you could make things a bit briefer, or what you could drop if needed. Otherwise, looks great!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Response to Skempt's article: Relational Understanding and Instrumental Understanding